Understand Car Accident Lawyer Fees Before You Sign

A settlement check can feel like the end of the road after a car crash. For many people, it’s the start of a second set of questions. If you’re asking what percentage lawyers take from a car accident settlement, the short answer is this: the percentage is set in a written fee agreement you sign with the lawyer, and it isn’t one fixed number.

This guide explains how that percentage works, what else can come out of a settlement, and what to ask before you sign. It’s general information for people hurt in New Mexico car crashes and for family members helping them decide.

Why the Percentage Can Change From Case to Case

The percentage depends on your written agreement, and that agreement can list more than one rate. New Mexico’s fee rule requires a contingent fee agreement to be in writing and signed by the client. The agreement must state the percentage the lawyer receives on settlement, at trial, and on appeal (Rule 16-105).

Because the rates can differ by stage, the percentage may change if a case settles early or goes to a lawsuit. Ask which rate applies at each stage before you sign. A written rate for each stage gives you something to check against the final numbers when the case closes.

Serious injury cases can take a long time to resolve, so the stage-by-stage terms are worth reading closely. Those terms belong in the signed document, not in a conversation alone.

If your injury involves the spinal cord, read our overview of spinal cord injury claims in New Mexico.

How Contingency Fees Work

A contingency fee is a fee tied to the money recovered, not to the hours billed. With an hourly fee, you pay for time spent. With a contingency fee, the lawyer’s share is a percentage of what the case recovers.

The written agreement also says whether that percentage is figured before or after case costs are subtracted. That choice changes the final number, so read it closely. A fee tied to a recovery can feel simpler than hourly billing, but the details decide how much you keep.

The fee depends on a recovery, but you may still owe costs. Under New Mexico’s fee rule, the agreement must clearly list any expenses you would owe even if the case produces no recovery (Rule 16-105). Court costs and litigation expenses are the usual examples. Your written agreement states which costs apply and how they are handled.

Ask about this part before you sign, because it is easy to skim past. The fee is also subject to a reasonableness standard, which the questions section below explains.

Case Costs and Expenses That Come Out of a Settlement

Case costs are out-of-pocket expenses for running the claim. They are separate from the lawyer’s percentage. Common examples include court filing fees, copies of medical and police records, imaging charges, deposition costs, and fees for reviewing the case with outside professionals.

Some agreements have the firm advance these costs while the case is open. The agreement says whether costs are advanced and how they are repaid. Costs can grow over a long case, so ask for each cost to be listed as it comes up. Keeping every cost statement helps you check the math at the end.

At the end of a contingent fee matter, the lawyer must give you a written statement of the outcome. If there is a recovery, that statement must show the payment to you and how it was figured (Rule 16-105). Keep the list of costs with your other case papers so you can compare it to that final statement.

Costs are different from medical bills, which are covered in the next section.

Medical Bills, Liens and Other Claims Against the Settlement

Medical bills and other third-party claims can be paid from a settlement, and they are separate from the attorney fee. Medicare Secondary Payer rules explain how Medicare can be repaid from a recovery.

Other providers, such as hospitals, may also assert claims against a settlement. How those claims are resolved depends on the facts and the agreements involved. Ask how each claim will be identified and paid before any funds are released.

If a state health program paid your care, see our guide to a Medicaid lien in a New Mexico car accident settlement. Amounts owed to these parties come out of what you keep, so count them from the start.

A Hypothetical Example: How a $75,000 Settlement Could Be Divided

Here is a made-up example, not a prediction: a $75,000 settlement, a 33⅓ percent fee on the full amount, and $4,000 in case costs.

1. Fee: $75,000 × 33⅓% = $25,000.
2. Costs: $4,000.
3. Left before any medical bills or liens: $75,000 − $25,000 − $4,000 = $46,000.

This example assumes the fee is figured before costs are subtracted. If your agreement works the other way, the numbers change. Any medical liens would reduce the $46,000 further, by an amount this example does not set.

This is an illustration only. It is not a prediction or a result for any client. Every case is different, and past results do not predict a similar outcome. Each line in the example matches a question you should ask before signing.

How injuries are documented also shapes a claim. For more on that, read spinal cord injury vs. nerve damage claims.

Is a 40 Percent Fee a Lot? Questions to Ask About Any Fee Agreement

A percentage is easier to judge when you know what it applies to, which costs come out, and who is paid first. A single percentage does not settle the question of whether a fee is fair. Read the whole agreement, including what the percentage is applied to.

New Mexico’s fee rule says a lawyer may not make an agreement for, charge or collect an unreasonable fee or an unreasonable amount for expenses (Rule 16-105).

Before you sign, ask:

• Is the percentage figured before or after case costs are subtracted?
• What percentage applies at settlement, at trial, and on appeal?
• Which costs will I owe if there is no recovery?
• How will medical bills and liens be paid from my share?
• How and when will costs be documented, and when will I receive the written outcome statement?

The fee rule says a new client must get at least a simple written memo of the fee terms before substantial services begin (Rule 16-105). Use those written answers to check the agreement, not your memory of a conversation.

Talk With El Gringo Law About Your Situation

If you’re trying to work out what a settlement could leave after fees, costs and bills, you may be doing it while still healing. Or you may be a family member making these calls for someone you love.

Our team can talk through your accident, your injuries and the questions in this guide with you. Our free first consultation is confidential and comes with no obligation to continue. En español: consulta inicial gratuita, confidencial y sin compromiso.

If that sounds useful, reach out to El Gringo Law through the contact page. You don’t need to have decided on a lawyer yet to ask questions.

Josh Wood, licensed in New Mexico and Arizona, is responsible for the content of this page.

Frequently Asked Questions